What Is Your Most Popular Flavor? Mango is Rita’s most popular flavor of Italian Ice. Coming in at number two is our famous Cherry Italian Ice, followed by Swedish Fish®.Click to see full answer. Correspondingly, what is good at Rita’s? The 15 Best Rita’s Italian Ice Flavors, Ranked Wild Black Cherry. PIN IT. Sour Patch Kids Red. PIN IT. Piña Colada. PIN IT. Mint Chocolate Chip. PIN IT. Cotton Candy. PIN IT. Passion Fruit. PIN IT. Photo courtesy of yelp.com. Grape. PIN IT. Photo courtesy of yelp.com. Peanut Butter & Jelly. PIN IT. Photo courtesy of @ritasice on Instagram. Beside above, what flavor custard does Rita’s have? Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (Trinity Point, PA) Our current lineup: Cotton Candy, Lemon, Mint, Orange Cream, Strawberry, Black Raspberry, Cake Batter, one more coming soon. We still carry our staples of Chocolate, Vanilla, and Twist. In this way, what is the Rita’s Unicorn flavor? Rita’s describes the new Unicorn Ice flavor as a sparkly strawberry candy flavored treat of happiness!What is a Rita’s concrete?THE CONCRETE. The richest, creamiest Frozen Custard swirled with toppings create a rich and decadent treat that will have you swooning.